How a puzzle is made
Every day's puzzle is seven prompts, and the same seven go to everyone at 08:00 UTC. A prompt that's too easy is dull, one that's too hard is frustrating, and seven of the same kind make a flat day. Here's how prompts are picked and put together.
What makes a good prompt
A good prompt has a crowd with a shape: a favourite that's clear but not overwhelming, and plenty of other answers people actually give. "Name a red fruit" works because apple leads but strawberry and cherry are close enough to matter. "Name a color" with no other words would be a poor one, because the answers scatter too widely, and a prompt where nearly everyone gives the same answer is a giveaway, not a game.
Prompts are about everyday things that most people share: food, homes, animals, routines, places, entertainment. The game stays away from politics, religion, violence and other topics that make answering feel uncomfortable, and every prompt is checked against that list before it can be used.
Testing a prompt before it plays
Before a prompt goes into the bank, it's tested against an estimated crowd: a simulated set of a few hundred answers, built to reflect how people tend to answer that kind of question. Two numbers from that estimate decide whether it passes:
- How big the top answer is. Each prompt has a difficulty. On an easy prompt the top answer should take roughly 30 to 45% of the crowd; on a medium one, about 18 to 35%; on a hard one, 10 to 25%. A favourite above 45% plays as a giveaway, so it doesn't pass.
- How many answers people really give. At least 10 to 15 different answers (depending on difficulty) must each get more than 1% of the crowd, so there's a real spread behind the leaders.
Prompts that are too close to one already in the bank are caught as duplicates. A person approves each prompt; one that fails a check can only go in with a written reason.
Putting seven together
Each day follows a few rules:
- An easy warm-up first. Prompt 1 has a clear favourite, so everyone starts with a fair chance.
- At least one contested prompt. Somewhere in the seven is a prompt where the top answer has a fifth of the crowd or less. These are the ones that separate good days from great ones.
- Variety. At least four different categories each day, and never two from the same category in a row.
The early crowd
The first players of the day would have nobody to match, so each prompt starts with the estimated crowd it was tested against. As real players finish a prompt, the estimate fades out, and it's gone entirely once a few hundred people have answered. From then on, the crowd is only real players.
Every prompt plays once
A prompt is used on one day only, ever. Once a puzzle is finished, its answers are published in the past puzzles for anyone to read, so reusing a prompt would hand returning players the answers. Every day's seven are new.
Have an idea for a prompt? Send it in. The best ones are everyday questions that you suspect most people would answer the same way, but not quite.